CASE STUDY #1
|
A
|
lmost every city street in London is under constant video surveillance,
partly as a reaction to terrorist attacks. These closed-circuit cameras initially
created tapes that could be viewed later, but the technology now is far more capable.
The cameras are equipped with automatic license plate recognition capabilities,
which use optical character recognition to decipher the license plate numbers and
letters in near real-time (Figure 4-29).
The camera’s data is sent to the national
ANPR Data Centre in north London, which also houses the Police National
Computer. Cameras are widespread throughout the city, and many are mounted on police
vehicles. Each camera can perform 100 million license plate reads per day. Each
vehicle’s plate number is combined with the camera’s GPS location and a timestamp,
so the Oracle database at the Data Center contains detailed information about
the whereabouts of almost every vehicle.
Since the database is linked to the
Police National Computer, police on the beat can query it to see whether a nearby
vehicle is flagged for some reason. Cross-checking the license plate information
against the crime database can turn up vehicles involved in crimes or registered
to wanted criminals. In one case, a police constable was killed during a
robbery, and police were able to track the getaway car because its license plate
was read by the cameras. For cameras mounted on vehicles, the officer does not
even need to send a query. An audio alert goes off when the camera’s image matches
a flagged license plate number, prompting the police to investigate.
Beyond criminal activity, the police database
contains extensive information linked to the license plate data. For instance, a
car might show that it is registered to someone who owes parking fines, or who
is uninsured. The data might also show that the license plate is attached to
the wrong vehicle, pointing to stolen plates.
The data are maintained for 5 years,
creating a rich repository for data mining. One study found that certain cars
triggered no flags, but seemed to be making impossibly quick journeys from one
end of town to the other. Police discovered that car thieves were trying to
outwit ANPR by “car cloning,” in which the perpetrators duplicate a real
license plate and attach it to a stolen car of the same make and model.
Law enforcement agencies see the
license plate database, the cameras that feed it, and its integration with
police data as a revolutionary advance, even though there are still gaps in
coverage and the technology itself is not perfect. For example, rain, fog, and
snow can interfere, and the plate itself might be blurred by mud. The plates
themselves vary quite a bit, with different colors, fonts, and background images.
Despite the drawbacks, police departments in the United States and other
countries are rapidly adopting the system, buying camera equipped cars, and
developing smartphone access to databases.
Privacy advocates, however, are
concerned about the mounting power of integrated databases and surveillance
technologies to scrutinize human behavior. One judge remarked, “A person who
knows all of another’s travels can deduce whether he is a weekly churchgoer, a heavy
drinker, a regular at the gym, an unfaithful husband, an outpatient receiving
medical treatment, or an associate of a particular individual or political
group.” The United Kingdom is tightening regulations to provide better
protections for citizens in an attempt to balance privacy concerns against the
enormous value these databases offer to law enforcement.
FIGURE 4-29
Capturing license plate numbers for law enforcement.
Source: Ann Cantelow/Shutterstock.
Discussion Questions
4-31. Describe
the manner in which data elements are linked across databases.
4-32. What
technical and physical challenges does this information system face?
4-33. What
human capital capabilities for law enforcement are necessary to make the database
more effective?
4-34. What are
the relevant considerations to balance the police’s ability to investigate versus
the citizens’ need for privacy?
Sources: Crump,
C. (March 19, 2013). ACLU in court today arguing that GPS tracking requires a warrant.
ACLU.org, http://www.aclu.org/blog/technology-and-liberty/aclu-courttoday-arguing-gps-tracking-requires-warrant,
accessed March 24, 2013.
Du, S., Ibrahim, M., Shehata, M., & Badawy, W. (2013). Automatic
license plate recognition (APLR): A state of the art review. IEEE Transactions
on Circuits & Systems for Video Technology (Feb. 2013), 23(2), 311–325.
Retrieved from Business Source Premier, April 4, 2013.
Mathieson, S. A., & Evans, R. (August 27, 2012). Roadside cameras
suffer from large gaps in coverage, police admin. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/aug/27/policenumber-plate-cameras-network-patchy,
accessed March 24, 2013.
National Vehicle Tracking Database,
http://wiki.openrightsgroup.org/wiki/National_Vehicle_Tracking_Database, accessed
March 24, 2013.
Police in Jackson, MS, use Genetec license plate recognition
technology. (March 14, 2013). Government Security News, http://www.gsnmagazine.com/node/28730?c=law_enforcement_first_responders,
accessed March 24, 2013.
~~~
Terjemahan dalam Bahasa Indonesia
BAB IV - STUDI KASUS #1
Polisi Inggris Lacak
Kendaraan Mencurigakan secara Real
Time dengan Kamera dan Database Plat Nomor Kendaraan
Hampir setiap jalan di kota London berada di bawah pengawasan kamera
video, hal ini dilakukan untuk reaksi terhadap serangan teroris. Dibuatnya CCTV
ini awalnya hanya berupa suatu rekaman yang bisa dilihat setelahnya m, tetapi
teknologi sekarang jauh lebih maju. Kamera sekaran ini telah dilengkapi dengan
kemampuan pengenalan plat otomatis, yang dimana menggunakan pengenalan karakter
optik untuk menguraikan nomor plat dan huruf dalam area yang dekat (Gambar
4-29).
Data kamera ini nantinya akan dikirim
ke ANPR yang terletak di utara London,
tempat ini juga merupakan kantor polri bagian komputer.Kamera-kamera ini tersebar luas di
seluruh kota, dan banyak yang dipasang pada kendaraan polisi. Setiap kamera dapat
membaca 100 juta plat per hari. Plat nomor setiap kendaraan dikombinasikan dengan
lokasi GPS kamera dan timestamp, sehingga database Oracle di Data Center berisi
informasi rinci tentang keberadaan hampir setiap kendaraan.
Karena database terkait dengan komputer
polisi nasional akhirnya mereka dapat melihat apakah kendaraan di dekatnya ditandai
untuk beberapa alasan. Terdapat silang informasi plat terhadap database kejahatan
yang dimana dapat muncul kendaraan yang terlibat dalam kejahatan ataj yang sedang
ingin melakukan kejahatan. Dalam satu kasus, seorang polisi tewas dalam perampokan,
dan polisi mampu melacak mobil tersebut karena platnya dapat terbaca oleh kamera.
Petugas tidak perlu meminta untuk memasang kamera pada kendaraannya. Terdapat
juga peringatan audio yang akan berbunyi jika gambar kamera cocok dengan nomor
plat yang ditandai, hal ini akan mendorong polisi untuk mendatangi atau
menyelidikinya.
Di luar kegiatan kriminal, database
polisi berisi informasi yang luas terkait dengan data plat. Misalnya, sebuah
mobil mungkin menunjukkan seseorang yang
berutang karena denda parkir, atau yang tidak diasuransikan. Data juga dapat
menunjukkan bahwa plat yang melekat pada kendaraan ternyata salah, hal ini dapat
menunjukkan suatu pencurian.
Data dapat dipertahankan atau disimpan
selama 5 tahun. Satu studi menemukan bahwa ada mobil yang dipicu dan ada bendera,
dan mobil itu seperti membuat perjalanan yang mustahil dari satu ujung kota yang
lain. Ternyata polisi menemukan bahwa pencuri mobil berusaha mengecoh ANPR oleh
"kloning mobil," di mana para pelaku menduplikasi plat nyata dan pasangkan
ke mobil curian dan membuat model yang sama.
Lembaga penegak hukum melihat database
plat,dan integrasi dengan data polisi sebagai revolusioner, meskipun masih ada
kekurangan dalam teknologi misalnya terdapat hujan, kabut, dan salju yang dapat
mengganggu, dan plat itu sendiri mungkin bisa tertutup lumpur dan juga berwarna-warni
atau berbeda" fontnya dan gambar background berbeda. Meskipun begitu, departemen
kepolisian di Amerika Serikat dan negara-negara lain dengan cepat mengadopsi
sistem, membeli mobil dengan kamera yang dilengkapi, dan juga mengembangkan akses
smartphone ke database.
Pendukung privasi bagaimanapun prihatin
tentang kekuatan pemasangan database yang terintegrasi dan teknologi pengawasan
untuk meneliti perilaku manusia. Satu hakim mengatakan, "Seseorang yang tahu
semua perjalanan lain dan juga dapat menyimpulkan apakah ia ke gereja setiap
minggu, peminum berat, biasa di gym, seorang suami yang tidak setia, pasien rawat
jalan yang menerima perawatan medis, atau asosiasi dari individu tertentu atau
kelompok politik. "Inggris memperketat peraturan untuk memberikan
perlindungan yang lebih baik bagi warga dalam upaya untuk menyeimbangkan masalah
privasi ini terhadap nilai yang sangat besar di database ini.
Sumber:
Wallace, Patricia. 2013. Information
Systems in Organizations: People, Technology, and Processes. Pearson-Prentice Hall. ISBN: 978-0-13-310452-3. p. 191
Crump, C. (March 19, 2013). ACLU in court today arguing that GPS
tracking requires a warrant. ACLU.org, http://www.aclu.org/blog/technology-and-liberty/aclu-courttoday-arguing-gps-tracking-requires-warrant,
accessed March 24, 2013.
Du, S., Ibrahim, M., Shehata, M., & Badawy, W. (2013). Automatic
license plate recognition (APLR): A state of the art review. IEEE Transactions
on Circuits & Systems for Video Technology (Feb. 2013), 23(2), 311–325.
Retrieved from Business Source Premier, April 4, 2013.
Mathieson, S. A., & Evans, R. (August 27, 2012). Roadside cameras
suffer from large gaps in coverage, police admin. The Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2012/aug/27/policenumber-plate-cameras-network-patchy,
accessed March 24, 2013.
National Vehicle Tracking Database, http://wiki.openrightsgroup.org/wiki/National_Vehicle_Tracking_Database,
accessed March 24, 2013.
Police in Jackson, MS, use Genetec license plate recognition
technology. (March 14, 2013). Government Security News, http://www.gsnmagazine.com/node/28730?c=law_enforcement_first_responders,
accessed March 24, 2013.
Pertanyaan Diskusi:
4-31. Describe
the manner in which data elements are linked across databases.
Dalam
teks case study dikatakan bahwa data
plat nomor kendaraan diintegrasikan antara kantor ANPR (Automatic Number Plate Recognition) dan
juga kantor polisi secara bersamaan untuk dilakukan cross check atau pengecekan berulang agar dapat mensesuaikan dengan
database yang sudah ada. Dan menurut sumber website resmi polisi di Inggris yang
kami pelajari [1] , saat ini terdapat 7750 kamera yang tersebar
diseluruh penjuru negeri. Kemudian hanya
petugas tertentu yang diberikan akses untuk bisa melacak rekaman 90 hari terakhir,
untuk beberapa kasus dan otoritas tertentu diberi akses untuk mampu melacak
hingga maksimal 2 tahun. Kami kira sangat berguna dan akan meningkatkan kemampuan
polisi dalam memberantas kejahatan. Dengan adanya kamera-kamera ini dan data yang
di-link lebih dari satu tempat, polisi bisa mendapatkan barang bukti misalnya
tindak kejahatan dengan mudah untuk digunakan dalam keperluan pengadilan.
4-32. What
technical and physical challenges does this information system face?
Secara
teknis dilapangan, system masih belum maksimal dalam ‘membaca’ plat nomor kendaraan
misalnya apabila cuaca mendung, cenderung gelap, berkabut, berdebu, bisa saja kamera
gagal mengidentifikasi plat nomor kendaraan tersebut. Namun seiring berjalannya
waktu, kami percaya bahwa kendala teknis akan semakin berkurang seinring berjalannya
waktu. Misalnya dengan meningkatkan kualitas kamera, atau mengkombinasikan antara
kamera untuk mendeteksi, serta memasang GPS untuk setiap plat nomor kedaraan.
Sehingga selain secara visual, tempat dimana kamera terpasang menggunakan
system seperti RFID [2] sehingga ketika sebuah mobil melewati kamera
tersebut, menggunakan RFID langsung terdeteksi. Sehingga gangguan-gangguan visual
sudah bukan menjadi masalah.
4-33. What
human capital capabilities for law enforcement are necessary to make the database
more effective?
Kemampuan sumber daya manusia yang
dibutuhkan dalam maksud untuk menegakan hukum menggunakan ANPR ini antara lain:
-
Memahami hukum yang berlaku bagi
staf pengelola data ini, sehingga bisa dipastikan setiap pelanggaran/kesalahan
pengguna jalan bisa ditindak lanjuti. Misalnya mengirim teguran atau denda ke alamat
plat nomor mobil tersebut terdaftar
-
Kemampuan untuk mengkomunikasikan
data tersebut, pada lembaga-lembaga yang pada awalnya tidak terintegrasi. Misalnya
pengadilan sebagai barang bukti yang kami kira sangat kuat
4-34. What are the relevant considerations to balance the police’s ability
to investigate versus the citizens’ need for privacy?
Walaupun
sangat kuat dan merupakan terobosan yang revolusional dalam bidang keamanan,
secara psikologis kota tersebut menjadi tidak lagi memiliki privasi sehingga
tidak membawa kenyamanan bagi masyarakatnya. Padahal usaha untuk menggunakan
teknologi ini dilakukan demi meningkatkan keamanan serta kenyamanan warganya.
Sehingga menurut hemat kami, demi tujuan kenyamanan tetapi tetap harus mengedepankan
keamanan serta ketertibkan, pihak berwenang harus menyeimbangkan kepentingan
investigasi dengan kenyamanan privasi masyarakat. Solusi agar tercapai keseimbangan
ini adalah seperti tidak membuka akses data ini bagi semua pihak, misalnya hanya
untuk polisi dengan tingkat jabatan tertentu dapat mengaakses data ini. Serta data
ini tidak boleh diunggah ke media social dan sejenisnya, sehingga benar-benar
memang data dikumpulkan untuk keamanan dan ketertiban masyarakat
Sumber:
[1] (2015). Automatic Number Plate Recognition. www.police.uk . diakses dari https://www.police.uk/information-and-advice/automatic-number-plate-recognition/
10 Oktober 2015 jam 15:00
[2] (2015).
RFID. Technovelgy. diakses dari
http://www.technovelgy.com/ct/Technology-Article.asp?ArtNum=2 10 Oktober 2015 jam
16:00
Answer Sheet in English
4-31. Describe
the manner in which data elements are linked across databases.
In the text of the case study said that the license plate numbers of data between offices integrated ANPR (Automatic Number Plate Recognition) and also
at the same, police station to do a cross check or recurring checks in order to adjust the existing database. And according to police sources the official website in the UK that we learned (www.police.uk), there are currently 7750 cameras that are scattered throughout the country. Then only certain officers were given access to be able to track record the past 90 days, for some cases and given access to certain authorities were able to track up to a maximum of 2 years. We think it is very useful and will enhance the ability of the police in combating crime. With the cameras and the data that is linked to more than one place, the police can obtain evidence of a crime with a simple example to use in court purposes.
4-32. What
technical and physical challenges does this information system face?
In the technical field, the system is still not maximized in 'reading' license plate numbers, for example, if the weather is cloudy, tend to be dark, foggy, dusty, could have the camera fails to identify the license plate number of the vehicle. But over time, we believe that the technical obstacles will wane over time. For example, by improving the quality of the camera, or combining a camera to detect and install the GPS for each vehicle license plates. So in addition to visually, where the camera is mounted using a system such as RFID so that when a car passes through the camera, using RFID directly detected. So that the visual disturbances has not been a problem.
4-33. What
human capital capabilities for law enforcement are necessary to make the database
more effective?
The ability of the human resources needed in the intention to enforce the law using ANPR, among others:
-‐ Understand the laws that apply to this data management staff, so that we can be sure every violation / road user errors can be followed up. Such as sending a reprimand or fine to the address of the registered car number plate
-‐ Ability to communicate these data, the institutions were not initially integrated. For instance court as evidence that we think is very strong
4-34. What are
the relevant considerations to balance the police’s ability to investigate
versus the citizens’ need for privacy?
Although it is very powerful and is
a revolutionary breakthrough in the field of security, psychologically the city
to its longer have any privacy, so its dont bring any comfort to the society.
Though attempts to use this technology is done in order to increase the safety
and comfort of its citizens. So in our opinion, for the purposes of convenience
but still must prioritize safety and orderliness, the authorities have to
balance the privacy interests of an investigation with the convenience of the
public. Solutions in order to achieve this balance is like not opening access
to this data for everyone, for example, only to the police with a certain
position level can access this data. And the data should not be uploaded to
social media, so the data is really
collected for security and public order.
--o0o--